What Not to Say to the Insurance Company After a Virginia Car Accident
If you were recently in a car accident in Virginia, you can expect to hear from the other driver’s insurer before long. Maybe you already have. While the adjuster on the other end of the line might seem helpful, it is important to understand that your well-being isn’t their primary concern. Rather, it’s their employer’s profits.
Say the wrong thing – even something as innocent as “I’m doing fine, thanks” – and you might give them an opening to devalue your claim or even deny it altogether.
This straightforward guide offers insights into what not to say to the insurance company, and why you should contact a car accident lawyer at Lichtenstein Law Group PLC.
Why Should I Be Cautious When Talking to the Insurance Company?
You should be cautious when talking to the insurance company for the simple reason that their needs are not aligned with yours. That is particularly true when dealing with the other driver’s insurance provider, which has no contractual obligations to you as a policyholder. Instead, the insurance company and the adjuster representing it want you on the record saying or doing something that lets them shift blame onto you.
You need to understand a few basic principles about car accident claims in Virginia. First, Virginia follows a traditional tort model for car insurance, which means the person who causes a car accident is financially responsible for the consequences other people suffer as a result, such as medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, and reduced quality of life.
The at-fault person’s auto insurance provider assumes liability, which could mean paying hundreds of thousands of dollars or more after a serious accident. The insurance company would much rather protect its money to pay its executives and shareholders than pay you as the accident victim.
Virginia still follows the strict contributory negligence rule when a personal injury victim is partially to blame for an accident. If you are found to be in any way at fault for the car accident, you will be barred from recovering any compensation at trial. The insurer will use the contributory negligence rule to their advantage by trying to get you to admit fault or pressuring you to take a lowball settlement.
What to Say — and Not Say — to the Adjuster
Be very careful when the other driver’s insurance company contacts you. Be polite, but keep things brief and factual. Perhaps more important than what you do say, though, is what you don’t. Here are a few things to avoid:
- DO NOT agree to give a recorded statement, as the insurance company can lock you into a version of events or turn your words against you later.
- DO NOT speculate about things you aren’t certain about.
- DO NOT say anything that might be interpreted as an admission of fault, such as “I should have seen them coming” or “I wish I had been more careful.”
- DO NOT downplay your car accident injuries or their severity, such as by saying “I’m fine” or “I’m doing OK.”
- DO NOT agree to a settlement offer without speaking to our personal injury lawyers first.
Do I Have to Speak to the Other Driver’s Insurance Company?
An insurance policy is a contract between the company that issues it and the person who purchases it. Part of that contract is an obligation to cooperate with the company’s investigation into an accident.
However, you are not a party to the contract the other driver signed with their insurer, and you do not have to speak with that company’s representatives. In fact, it is almost always a good idea not to. Be polite, but tell the adjuster you are engaging legal representation and that your lawyer will contact them shortly.
Should I Agree to Give a Recorded Statement?
Insurance companies often ask accident victims to give a recorded statement to help process a claim or aid the investigation. The adjuster might tell you that it is the company’s practice and that their hands are tied. A prerecorded voice at the beginning of the call might tell you that conversations may be monitored for quality assurance.
But remember: you are under no obligation to provide a recorded statement, and in fact, it is probably not in your best interest to do so. Whatever you say becomes a permanent part of the record. Your memory may be fuzzy, or you may misstate something in the moment. Regardless, the insurance company can use it later to suggest you were at fault, downplay your injuries, or undermine your credibility.
Politely decline to speak with an adjuster on the record and tell them that you are seeking legal counsel who will get back to them soon.
How a Virginia Auto Accident Attorney Can Help You Deal with Insurance Companies
The good news is that you can hire someone to deal with the insurance company for you. In fact, that is one of the biggest services that personal injury attorneys provide. Instead of worrying about your claim or what you say to insurance adjusters, you can focus on attending medical appointments, healing from your injuries, and spending time with your family.
While you focus on rebuilding your future after an accident, your lawyer can:
- Independently investigate the accident rather than relying on the insurance company’s evidence.
- Respond to requests for comment, represent you during necessary interactions with the insurance company, and advise you on safe responses when you have to provide them.
- Work with experts to calculate the full value of your case and understand the compensation you’re entitled to.
- Negotiate a fair settlement with the insurance company, and take your case to trial if they won’t offer one.
Our experienced Virginia car accident attorneys will do all the work at no upfront cost to you. The personal injury lawyers with Lichtenstein Law Group PLC work on a contingency-fee basis. That means you pay our attorney’s fees only if and when we secure compensation for you.
Contact a Virginia Car Accident Lawyer
Don’t make the mistake of dealing with the insurance companies on your own. Instead, get help from an experienced Virginia car accident law firm that knows how to handle insurance adjusters while seeking fair compensation for you.
Contact Lichtenstein Law Group PLC today for a free consultation with an experienced personal injury attorney about your legal options after a car crash.
Tap to Call