What Is Summary Judgment in a Virginia Personal Injury Case?
Personal injury lawsuits can end in a judgment for one party before the case reaches trial. A party may file a summary judgment motion asking the court to decide the case, or certain outstanding issues, in their favor.
The court may grant a summary judgment motion when it finds no material facts in dispute and concludes that the record requires judgment for the moving party as a matter of law. Summary judgment proceedings in personal injury cases can resolve claims more quickly than waiting for trial or help narrow the scope of disputed issues for trial or further settlement negotiations.
What Is Summary Judgment?
Summary judgment is a procedural tool in a lawsuit in which a party formally asks the presiding judge to rule in the party’s favor on one or more issues based on the evidence in the record. Under the summary judgment legal standard, a court considers the undisputed facts and views the evidence in favor of the non-moving party.
Virginia law under Va. Code § 8.01-420 prohibits parties from basing a summary judgment motion on discovery depositions unless all parties in the case agree to their use.
Based on the facts in the record, the court must determine if the law requires judgment in favor of the moving party. The court must deny a summary judgment motion if it finds that one or more genuine issues of material facts remain disputed, requiring a trial to resolve those disputes.
Who Can File for Summary Judgment?
Under Va. Code § 8.01-377.1, any party in a personal injury lawsuit can file a summary judgment motion. In a summary judgment motion, the moving party argues that the facts in the record show that the court should rule on a particular issue in the case for the moving party as a matter of law.
Both plaintiffs and defendants can move for summary judgment when they believe the record clearly supports a ruling in their favor.
How Summary Judgment Applies to Personal Injury Claims
In personal injury cases (car accidents or truck accidents, for instance), summary judgment can resolve a claim in its entirety or only a portion of the case. For example, summary judgment could resolve liability while leaving the issue of compensation for trial.
A defendant may move for summary judgment to dismiss the claims against them, while leaving other defendants in the case. A judge’s decision on a motion for summary judgment that resolves the entire personal injury claim can either end the entire case in the defendant’s favor or result in a compensation award for the plaintiff.
The Steps of a Summary Judgment Motion
A summary judgment proceeding begins when one party files a motion for summary judgment. The motion should identify whether the moving party seeks partial summary judgment to resolve only some of the issues in a case or summary judgment on all the issues in the case.
The moving party must also submit a written brief presenting the facts in the record and citing applicable law to argue why the court should grant judgment in the party’s favor.
After the moving party files a summary judgment motion, the opposing party may file a brief contesting the arguments in the moving party’s motion. The opposing party can also file a cross-motion for summary judgment, arguing that the record instead supports a judgment in their favor.
Following the parties’ briefings, the court may schedule a summary judgment hearing for the parties to present oral arguments in favor of their respective positions. At oral argument, the judge may also ask questions to better understand the arguments made in the briefs.
What Happens if the Summary Judgment Motion Is Granted or Denied?
When a court denies a summary judgment motion in a personal injury lawsuit, the case continues to proceed toward trial as before the motion. A party who files an unsuccessful summary judgment motion can refile it later if more facts enter the record.
If a trial judge grants summary judgment, what happens next depends on the motion’s scope. Because summary judgment does not need to resolve all issues in a case, a lawsuit can continue after a court grants a summary judgment motion to resolve the remaining issues not covered by the motion. For example, a personal injury plaintiff may successfully move for summary judgment on the issue of a defendant’s liability, after which the case may proceed to a subsequent summary judgment motion or to trial on the matter of the plaintiff’s compensation.
However, if a summary judgment motion seeks to resolve all issues in the case and the court grants it, the case ends with a final judgment in either the plaintiff’s or defendant’s favor.
Will a Summary Judgment Have an Effect on Settlement Negotiations?
A summary judgment motion can sometimes provide a party with leverage in settlement negotiations. The possibility of a summary judgment motion, and the risk of the court granting it, can induce an opposing party to agree to a settlement to avoid an adverse judgment.
For example, a defendant may agree to settle when faced with a potential summary judgment motion that could result in a larger award for the plaintiff.
Partial summary judgment can also affect settlement negotiations by resolving some issues in the case and narrowing the scope of the dispute between the parties. Narrowing down the disputed issues can help the parties assess the strengths and weaknesses of their respective cases. Summary judgment can also help parties focus their negotiations.
Contact a Virginia Personal Injury Lawyer
If you’ve been hurt in an accident that someone else caused, you might have the opportunity to secure a successful outcome before trial through a summary judgment motion. The personal injury attorneys at Lichtenstein Law Group PLC can meet with you for a free consultation and explain what to expect in your case.
Contact us today for a free consultation with a personal injury attorney to learn more about the process of seeking summary judgment in your case.
Tap to Call